Three little bits…

First …

I read a really annoying essay on a substack called Raised by Germans. It’s all about a girl who grew up in the 90’s and was, shocker of shockers, a tomboy. She thinks it was a new thing.

I can’t really tell much about this substack writer but I want to know how she missed out on people like Laura Ingalls Wilder, a real person, who did a lot of boy things, or Caddie Woodlawn, a more or less fictional tomboy, written in the 1930’s. How about Kate in The Good Master? Kate was a quintessential tomboy, saved from complete ruination of her character, by being allowed to run free on a farm, though the story is set around 1912 in Hungary. (The substack writer might have grown up in Germany, or grown up here with German parents. I didn’t look too far into it.)

One thing that the stories I mentioned all have in common is that the tomboys ultimately learn to value the feminine side of things, one way or another, without giving up their other likings. This is especially interesting because in these stories incredible hard work is the norm. Laura, and Caddie, and Kate were working harder than Ms. Substack can probably imagine. The American West of the 1800’s was a hard place and so was Hungary, even before World War. Kate had to do a lot of men’s work when World War I took the farmhands to the war and killed them.

That leaves me thinking that a little humility about the past from Ms. Substack would be welcome. She sees that something has gone wrong, because tomboys are no longer allowed, but she doesn’t seem to understand how it happened; she credits feminism with giving her a free childhood, but she’d do better to realize that freedom came from the inventors of washers and dryers, reapers and harvesters, cars, trains, planes, etc. And from the Christian idea that men and women are both created in God’s image.

The specific problem that Mr. American-in-Paris discusses, is an announcement on the Paris subways explaining in English, French, and, maybe Italian or Spanish, that a given stop goes to the airport. The German announcement says that the stop will take you to Disneyland. This causes German speakers to jump off the train in a great panic — when they absolutely should not. The writer spends several years watching this problem, and trying to contact authority to fix it. The essay is quite funny and I enjoyed it without taking its commentary on the French character too seriously.

Third, I am still preparing for the Shenandoah Valley Fiber Festival this weekend, September 27 and 28.

Enough said!

3 thoughts on “Three little bits…

    1. Thanks for the comment. The Singing Tree also showed how hard it was for the women and children to manage when the men were all gone, though they tried really hard. I really loved reading about WWI from a totally different perspective. Seredy wrote another book called The Chestry Oak that’s also from a very different friends/enemies perspective during WWII.

      >

      Liked by 1 person

      1. You’re welcome! *Chestry Oak,” I have to look that up. For an enemies/friends story, I highly recommend Constance Savery’s *Enemy Brothers,* also set in WWII. Though this time, it’s in England, and the younger boy was kidnapped to Germany long before the War began….

        Like

Leave a reply to catholicfictioncatholicscience Cancel reply